Last updated: November 2, 2026.
Is there a good way to talk with kids about a time-travel book set in 1876? This guide for parents and teachers has discussion questions, new words and printable extras for The Wrong Choice, Book 1 of the TRACE in Colorado series. It is written for readers about 9 to 12.

Quick facts
๐
Book
The Wrong Choice by T. A. Held, Book 1 of The Riddle America Cannot Explain: TRACE in Colorado.
๐
Age
9 to 12.
๐
Setting
Morrison and Denver, Colorado, in 1876.
๐
In every book
a What Was Real? page that separates the facts from the fiction.
๐ก Did you know? In Coloradoโs social studies standards, grade 8 covers U.S. history from the American Revolution through Reconstruction, so a story set in 1876 sits near the end of that period.
About the book
Two boys, Alex and Daniel, run from a storm into a cabin that is not on any map. A journal in the cellar and a red stone with two triangles pull them back to 1876, with no money and nowhere to sleep. Somewhere along the way they make the wrong choice, and now they must find out what it was. The story is made up, but the history around it is real.
Questions to talk about
- The boys arrive with no money and nowhere to sleep. What would you do first?
- Why might it be hard to explain to people in 1876 where you came from?
- The bookโs title is about a wrong choice. Can you think of a time when you made a choice and only later understood it?
- What does it feel like to be new in a place where you do not know the rules?
- Which things about daily life in 1876 would you miss most from today?
- Why does a book that ends with a What Was Real? page help readers trust the history?
New words in 1876
๐
Statehood
becoming a state. Colorado became a state on August 1, 1876.
๐
Centennial
a hundredth anniversary. Colorado is the Centennial State.
๐
Telegraph
a machine that sent messages as clicks along a wire.
๐
Assay
to test how pure a metal is.
๐
Teamster
a person who drives a team of animals pulling a wagon.
๐
Toll road
a road that charges a fee to use it.
๐
Locust
a kind of grasshopper that can fly in huge swarms.
Read the history behind the story
These short history posts match the book and make good reading for class or home: When did Colorado become a state?, Elias Ammons, Denver for kids in 1876, How news travelled in 1876, The grasshopper plague, Hauling lumber near Morrison, Hotels in Denver in 1876 and a Denver 1876 trivia quiz.
Free printable extras
The site has printable bonuses for readers. Find out how to use them here: bookmarks, puzzle, trivia cards and time-traveler passport.
Classroom ideas
- Make a timeline with 1859, 1863, 1874 and 1876 and add events from the history posts.
- Choose one real job from 1876, such as lamplighter or teamster, and write a short diary entry from that personโs day.
- Compare how news travelled in 1876 with how it travels today.
What is real and what is made up
The boys and their adventure are made up. The history in the book, and the history in our posts, is real. Every book ends with a What Was Real? page so readers can tell the difference.
How to use this guide
Before reading, ask your child what they already know about 1876, and what might be hard for two boys who arrive with no money. While reading, stop now and then to ask what the boys know and what they do not. After reading, turn to the What Was Real? page at the end of the book and ask which facts surprised your child. This simple routine works well at home, in a classroom or in a library reading group.
This story comes from TRACE in Colorado by T. A. Held, a time-travel series for ages 9 to 12 with a What Was Real? page in every book.
Read the book: The Wrong Choice (Book 1) ยท See all the TRACE in Colorado books
Previous post: Trivia quiz: Denver in 1876 (3 questions with answers)

Leave a Reply