Last updated: November 20, 2026.
Looking for a holiday gift for a kid who loves history, mysteries or time travel? A good book is the gift that keeps going long after the wrapping paper is gone. Here are six gift books for kids ages 9 to 12: a snowed-in inn full of strangers at Christmas, a medieval road trip with a holy dog, a magic harmonica, and two boys who fall into Colorado in 1876. Each one has a short card, a closer look underneath, and a quick chooser at the bottom.
All six are stories where the past matters. Some are set in history, some mix a real place with a mystery, and one sends two kids from today back in time.
What makes a great gift book for ages 9 to 12
- A story they can sink into over the winter break: long enough to last, exciting enough to keep going.
- A mystery or a secret: a hidden map, a strange harmonica, a stone that opens onto the past.
- A real place and time: France in 1242, Germany in 1933, New York in 1927, Colorado in 1876.
- Something extra: pictures, a game, or a free printable to tuck inside the wrapping.
Where (and when) these books go: a quick timeline
- 1242: roads and inns of medieval France. The Inquisitor’s Tale
- 1876: Morrison and Denver, the year Colorado became a state. The Wrong Choice
- 1927 and 1977: Hoboken, New Jersey, Gunflint Lake, Minnesota, and a famous New York museum. Wonderstruck
- 1933 to the 1940s: Germany, Pennsylvania and California. Echo
- Long ago and today: a dry lake in Texas with a buried secret. Holes
- Christmas, any year: an old smugglers’ inn on a cliff. Greenglass House
The books
1. Greenglass House
📖 Holiday mystery · ✍️ Kate Milford · 2014 · Edgar Award for best children’s mystery · about 400 pages

It’s the start of winter break, and nobody ever comes to Milo’s family inn at Christmas. Then five strangers arrive, one after another, and every one of them has a secret.
👍 Good for kids who love a cozy snowed-in mystery, secret maps and smugglers.
More about Greenglass House
Milo Pine is twelve, and his parents run Greenglass House, an old inn on the cliffs that has always been friendly to smugglers. Milo was hoping for a quiet holiday. Instead the bell keeps ringing, and Milo finds an old map that seems to be connected to the strangers. With Meddy, the cook’s daughter, he starts a role-playing game to investigate the guests, and soon things begin to go missing.
The book won the Edgar Allan Poe Award for best children’s novel and was nominated for the National Book Award. Because it takes place during the Christmas holidays, it is a perfect book to open in December and read by the fire.
2. Holes
📖 Mystery adventure · ✍️ Louis Sachar · 1998 · Newbery Medal and National Book Award · ages 10 and up

Stanley Yelnats is sent to a camp in the Texas desert for a crime he didn’t do. Every day he has to dig a hole. What are they really looking for?
👍 Good for kids who like a puzzle where every piece clicks into place at the end.
More about Holes
Stanley is blamed for a theft and sent to Camp Green Lake, which has no lake at all. Each boy digs one big hole a day. As Stanley digs, the book tells two more stories: one about his great-great-grandfather in Latvia and one from long ago in the same Texas valley. Slowly the three stories come together.
Holes won the National Book Award in 1998 and the Newbery Medal in 1999, and in a 2012 School Library Journal survey it was ranked number six among all-time children’s novels. The publisher suggests it for ages 10 and up. Bonus gift idea: watch the 2003 movie together after the book.
3. The Wrong Choice (TRACE in Colorado, Book 1)
📖 Time-travel mystery · ✍️ T. A. Held · The Riddle America Cannot Explain: TRACE in Colorado · ages 9 to 14
Alex and Daniel only wanted to get out of the rain. Then a red stone in a cabin cellar drops them on a hill above Morrison, Colorado, in 1876.
👍 Good for kids who want time travel, a riddle to solve and a What Was Real? page at the end.
More about The Wrong Choice
There are no cabins in the park. Daniel has seen the map. But in the storm the two boys find one anyway, with a door in the floor, a red rock with two triangles cut into it, and an old journal lying open on a table. Then the floor begins to hum.
Now they are in 1876, with no money, nowhere to sleep and nobody who would ever believe where they came from. Somewhere along the way they made the wrong choice, and the stone won’t open again until they find out what it was. How do you fix a mistake when you don’t even know you made it?
The places are real. 1876 is the year Colorado became a state. Want the true story behind the book? Read the quiet day Colorado became a state, what Denver was like for kids in 1876 and the grasshopper plague of 1876, then try the Denver 1876 quiz.
🎁 Gift tip: the book page for The Wrong Choice has free trivia cards, three bookmarks, a passport sticker and a 48-piece puzzle to print at home, no sign-up needed. Print a bookmark and tuck it inside the book before you wrap it.
The Wrong Choice is Book 1 of The Riddle America Cannot Explain: TRACE in Colorado by T. A. Held, a time-travel series for ages 9 to 14. A series is a great gift: if they love the first book, the next one is ready.
4. Echo
📖 Historical novel with a fairy tale · ✍️ Pam Muñoz Ryan · Scholastic, 2015 · Newbery Honor, 2016 · a long book (about 580 pages)

One harmonica marked with a red letter M. Three kids in three places, in the years before and during World War II, and each one needs it.
👍 Good for kids who love music, big stories and a fairy tale that turns out to be connected to everything.
More about Echo
The book begins like a fairy tale, with a boy named Otto lost in a forest. Then the harmonica travels: to Friedrich in Germany in 1933, who works at a harmonica factory; to two orphan brothers, Mike and Frankie, in Pennsylvania during the Great Depression; and to Ivy Lopez in Southern California just after the United States enters World War II. At the end, all the stories meet.
Echo was a Newbery Honor book in 2016 and one of Kirkus Reviews’ best books of 2015. It is long and has some serious moments (Nazi Germany, an orphanage, unfair treatment of families during the war), so it is a wonderful book to read aloud together over the holidays.
5. The Inquisitor’s Tale
📖 Medieval adventure · ✍️ Adam Gidwitz · illustrated by Hatem Aly · Dutton, 2016 · Newbery Honor · ages 10 and up

France, 1242. Travelers at an inn tell stories about three children with strange powers and their dog, and the king’s men are chasing all of them.
👍 Good for kids who love knights, funny adventures and stories told around a fire.
More about The Inquisitor’s Tale
On a March night in 1242, travelers at an inn near Paris take turns telling what they know. Jeanne can see the future. William is a young monk with enormous strength. Jacob can heal almost any wound. With Gwenforte, a greyhound who may be a saint, they become outlaws, and there is even a dragon with a very smelly problem.
The adventure is wrapped around real history from 1242, when King Louis IX had copies of the Talmud, a Jewish holy book, burned in Paris. The book was a Newbery Honor book and won the Sydney Taylor Book Award. The publisher suggests it for ages 10 and up.
6. Wonderstruck
📖 Story in words and pictures · ✍️ Brian Selznick · Scholastic, 2011 · by the creator of The Invention of Hugo Cabret

Two kids, fifty years apart, both run away to New York. One story is told in words, the other in pictures, until they meet.
👍 Good for kids who love to pore over pictures, museums, and a book that feels like a treasure to unwrap.
More about Wonderstruck
Ben’s story starts in Gunflint Lake, Minnesota, in June 1977. After a lightning strike leaves him deaf, he runs away to New York to find the father he never knew and hides in the American Museum of Natural History. Rose’s story starts in Hoboken, New Jersey, in October 1927. She is deaf too, and she runs away to New York to see a movie star.
Ben’s chapters are written in words and Rose’s are told in Brian Selznick’s drawings, and at the end the two stories come together. It is a thick book that reads fast, and it makes a beautiful gift.
How to choose
- For a cozy holiday mystery: Greenglass House.
- For a kid who loves a puzzle that clicks together at the end: Holes.
- For a mystery lover who wants time travel, real history and a What Was Real? page: The Wrong Choice.
- For a music lover or a family read-aloud: Echo.
- For a kid who loves knights, dragons and funny adventures: The Inquisitor’s Tale.
- For a kid who loves pictures, or a reluctant reader: Wonderstruck.
Talk about it
If you could find one secret object hidden in your house, what would you want it to be: an old map, a harmonica, or a stone that opens onto the past? And if you could spend one holiday in any year in history, which year would you pick?
More book lists
Love mysteries? Try mystery and riddle books for kids or heist and detective books. Want time travel? Try books for kids who love Magic Tree House or time-travel books with a girl hero. Want winter? See snow and mountain adventure books. Or start in 1876 with books set in the 1870s.
This list comes from TRACE in Colorado by T. A. Held, a time-travel series for ages 9 to 14 with a What Was Real? page in every book.
Read the book: The Wrong Choice (Book 1) · See all the TRACE in Colorado books
Sources
- Greenglass House (Wikipedia)
- Greenglass House (Kirkus Reviews)
- Holes (Wikipedia)
- Holes by Louis Sachar (Brightly, Penguin Random House)
- Echo (Wikipedia)
- Echo (Kirkus Reviews)
- Echo, Newbery Honor 2016 (American Library Association)
- The Inquisitor's Tale (Wikipedia)
- The Inquisitor's Tale (Brightly, Penguin Random House)
- Wonderstruck (Wikipedia)
