Last updated: November 6, 2026.
What would you do if you wanted to be the first person to find a new dinosaur, and your biggest rival wanted the same thing? In the 1870s two American scientists had exactly that problem, and they fought over fossils for years. People later named the fight the Bone Wars.
This post explains who the two scientists were, what they did, and why a few small Colorado towns, including Morrison, became part of the story.
Quick facts
🎓
Marsh
Othniel Charles Marsh worked at Yale. He paid for the first dinosaur bones from Morrison, Colorado.
🔬
Cope
Edward Drinker Cope worked in Philadelphia. He was Marsh’s rival.
🤫
A secret name
In a telegram, Professor Mudge called Cope “Jones” so nobody reading it would know who he meant.
⏳
A long feud
The Bone Wars ran from 1877 to 1892, and both men found many new kinds of dinosaurs.
💡 Did you know? In 1877 people paid for telegrams by the word, so they left out every word they could. Mudge’s telegram said that an arrangement was made for two months and that Jones “cannot interfere”.
The Bone Wars around Colorado, 1877
March 20
Arthur Lakes and Henry Beckwith find the first bone near Morrison (most accounts).
After the find
Lakes writes to Marsh. With no answer, he sends samples to Cope. Marsh sends $100.
July 1
Marsh publishes the Morrison finds.
August 8
Mudge opens Felch Quarry 1 near Canon City for Marsh, with Samuel Williston and Marshall Felch. It runs until October 27.
1877 to 1884
Oramel and Ira Lucas dig in Garden Park near Canon City for Cope.
Two scientists, two cities
Marsh lived and worked at Yale, in Connecticut. Cope lived and worked in Philadelphia. Both were experts on old bones, and both wanted to describe as many new dinosaurs as they could. Whoever described a new animal first got to give it its name.
That sounds like a friendly contest. It was not. Each man tried to get the best fossil sites, and each tried to keep the other away from them.
How Colorado joined in
The first Colorado bones came from the ridge north of Morrison. Arthur Lakes wrote to Marsh about them. When Marsh did not answer, Lakes sent samples to Cope. As soon as Marsh heard that, he sent Lakes $100 and then sent a helper, Professor Benjamin Mudge, to make sure Lakes kept working for him.
Mudge was about sixty years old in 1877. He had taught at the Kansas State Agricultural College in Manhattan, Kansas. In a telegram to Marsh he wrote that a satisfactory arrangement was made for two months and that Jones, the code word for Cope, “cannot interfere”. The secret code was a way to keep news from reaching the other side.
The fight spreads to Canon City
At almost the same time, bones were found near Canon City, in southern Colorado. A teacher named O. W. Lucas found them and wrote to Cope. Later, Marsh asked Mudge to win Lucas over, but Lucas stayed loyal to Cope. Oramel and Ira Lucas dug in the Garden Park quarries for Cope from 1877 to 1884.
Marsh answered by opening his own quarry nearby. Mudge, Samuel Williston and Marshall Felch worked Felch Quarry 1 for him from August 8 to October 27, 1877.
Workers who changed sides
Both men paid diggers, and the diggers sometimes switched sides. In 1872 two of Cope’s men were also taking money from Marsh. In the winter of 1878, W. E. Carlin left Marsh and went to work for Cope.
A mistake about the plates
Marsh did not always get things right. When he first saw the strange bony plates of a Stegosaurus, he thought they might come from a giant sea turtle. Later he decided the plates lay flat on the animal’s back like roof shingles. Today scientists think the plates stood up in rows.
How did it end?
By 1892 the Bone Wars were over. The two men had named an enormous number of dinosaurs between them. Some of the names we all know today, such as Stegosaurus, Allosaurus and Apatosaurus, come from this period. The way it was done was often rough, but the fossils they saved are still studied.
Want to read more?
To see how Colorado fit into the story, read The 1877 dinosaur rush near Morrison.
What is real and what is made up
These parts are real: Marsh, Cope, Mudge, Lakes, Williston, the Lucas brothers, the telegram, the $100 and the dates of Felch Quarry 1.
These parts are explained in simple words: the Bone Wars lasted many years and many states, and this post only covers the Colorado part in detail.
This is a history post. It does not tell the plot of any story.
This story comes from TRACE in Colorado by T. A. Held, a time-travel series for ages 9 to 14 with a What Was Real? page in every book.
Read the book: Who Drew Us? (Book 5) · See all the TRACE in Colorado books
Previous post: The 1877 dinosaur rush near Morrison, Colorado
Next post: Arthur Lakes: the teacher who found the first Stegosaurus

Leave a Reply