Last updated: November 4, 2026.
Five books for readers who love puzzles, secrets and mysteries: a game with sixteen strangers, a stolen painting, a time-travel mystery in Colorado, two kids who run away to a museum and a team of four children on a secret mission. Each one has a closer look underneath, and a quick chooser at the bottom if you cannot decide.
What these books have in common
Every book on this list is built around a puzzle, a secret or a question that the characters must solve. Two of them, The Westing Game (1978) and From the Mixed-Up Files of Mrs. Basil E. Frankweiler (1967), won the Newbery Medal. Chasing Vermeer was published in 2004 and The Mysterious Benedict Society in 2007.
Opening Soon adds time travel and real Colorado history to the mix. In each TRACE in Colorado book the places and events are real, and a What Was Real? page at the end tells which parts are history and which are made up.
How to choose
Read the short description on each card first. Then open the “More about” part underneath to see who wrote the book, when it came out and what happens at the start. The chooser at the bottom matches each book to a kind of reader.
More about The Westing Game
The Westing Game was published by Dutton on May 1, 1978, and won the Newbery Medal. A 2012 survey published by School Library Journal ranked it ninth among children’s novels of all time.
The story begins on the Fourth of July, when sixteen strangers receive personal invitations to rent apartments in the new Sunset Towers. It was adapted as the 1997 film Get a Clue, also released as The Westing Game.
More about Chasing Vermeer
Chasing Vermeer is set in Hyde Park, Chicago, near the University of Chicago. It follows two children, Calder Pillay and Petra Andalee.
After the painting A Lady Writing by Johannes Vermeer is stolen on its way to the Art Institute of Chicago, Calder and Petra work together to recover it. The thief publishes advertisements in the newspaper saying he will give the painting back if the community can find out which paintings under Vermeer’s name were really painted by him.
3. Opening Soon (TRACE in Colorado, Book 3)
🎂 Ages 9 to 12 · 📍 Colorado, 1993 to 1995 · ✍️ T. A. Held
Somebody is sending messages to the past, and he is the one who reads them.
👍 Good for kids who like time travel, secret chalk messages and a giant airport that is always opening soon.
More about Opening Soon (TRACE in Colorado, Book 3)
Opening Soon is the third book in The Riddle America Cannot Explain: TRACE in Colorado, a time-travel series by T. A. Held. Each book has a What Was Real? page that tells which parts are real history and which parts are made up.
Alex, Daniel and Maya arrive in the cellar of a Colorado cabin in August 1993. An old man named Walter lives upstairs. Somebody writes messages on the stone in chalk and signs them D.W., and each one tells something nobody could know yet. Some are about a box of sensors, and some are about Denver’s giant new airport, which is always opening soon and never opens. Then the three get split up. Read the real story behind the airport here: Why was Denver’s new airport always opening soon?.
More about From the Mixed-Up Files of Mrs. Basil E. Frankweiler
The book follows siblings Claudia and Jamie Kincaid as they run away from home to the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York City. Atheneum published it in 1967, and it won the Newbery Medal in 1968.
The story opens with a letter from Mrs. Basil E. Frankweiler to her lawyer.
More about The Mysterious Benedict Society
The series follows four children gathered together by the eccentric Mr. Benedict: Reynie Muldoon, Sticky Washington, Kate Wetherall and Constance Contraire. They work together to stop Ledroptha Curtain, Mr. Benedict’s twin brother, from taking over the world.
The first three books came out once a year from 2007 to 2009, and a fourth followed about a decade later.
Which one should you pick?
- Want a clue-filled game with lots of characters? Try The Westing Game.
- Like art and puzzles? Try Chasing Vermeer.
- Love time travel and real Colorado history? Try Opening Soon.
- Want a classic about hiding in a museum? Try From the Mixed-Up Files of Mrs. Basil E. Frankweiler.
- Want a whole series about four children on a mission? Start with The Mysterious Benedict Society.
This is a short list, and more books will be added over time. If you have a favorite mystery for kids, tell us.
This story comes from TRACE in Colorado by T. A. Held, a time-travel series for ages 9 to 12 with a What Was Real? page in every book.
Read the book: Opening Soon (Book 3) · See all the TRACE in Colorado books
Next post: Why was Denver’s new airport always “opening soon”? The story of 1993 to 1995




